David Justice Takes Issue with ‘Moneyball’ Portrayal 13 Years After Movie’s Release as Ex-Oakland Star Disputes ‘Pep Talk’ Scene
The film, based on Michael Lewis’s book of the same name, depicts Justice as somewhat of a selfish player. Justice recently appeared on Keyshawn Johnson’s ‘All Facts, No Brakes’ podcast to challenge how screenwriters and actor Stephen Bishop played him.
“There’s a scene in ‘Moneyball’ where my character makes a comment about it costing money to get a drink,” Justice recounted, referencing the moment where the actor playing him questions why soda costs $1 in the clubhouse.
He also pointed out another scene where the general manager, played by Brad Pitt, talks to Justice in the batting cage about needing him to step up as a leader. “It portrays me like I’m talking to the general manager, saying, ‘Listen, y’all paying me my salary; don’t even come in here and talk to me,'” Justice explained, noting that this clip shows his character asking what’s in it for him to be a leader.
Justice firmly disputed this portrayal. “First of all, my mama would’ve killed me if she saw me even remotely disrespecting a coach, a manager, or someone like that,” he emphasized, highlighting his upbringing and respect for authority figures.
In the podcast episode, Justice also addressed his real-life relationship with A’s general manager, Billy Beane, underscoring that he fully understood his role and expectations from the outset. “This was my last year in the big leagues,” he said. “The first day of spring training, I already knew what it was going to be about. Billy Beane… never had to have a conversation with me.”
During the 2002 season, Justice batted .266 with an on-base percentage of .376 and a slugging percentage of .410, hitting 11 home runs and 49 RBIs in 118 games. His actual demeanor and understanding of his leadership role starkly contrast with the film’s portrayal, shedding light on the often complex balance between dramatic storytelling and accurate representation in sports films.